Commit Graph
3 Commits
Author SHA1 Message Date
Quick 90224c583f fix(settings): clear the remaining review findings
Small, unrelated except that each was raised on #479.

compileObjectSchemas parsed every non-directory file under schemas/ as a JSON
Schema, so a stray editor backup or .DS_Store would panic the server at
startup through MustLoad. schema_ref can only name a .json file; anything
else is skipped.

cmd/silo used MustLoad while the ETag check beside it and every other startup
failure use log.Fatalf. It now fails the same way, so a bad contract prints
an error instead of a stack trace.

TestRegistryDefaultsMatchTheContract called scalarDefault before handling
null, and scalarDefault rejects null as non-scalar — so the subtest skipped
and the comparison after it was unreachable. A nullable contract default
could disagree with a non-empty registry default and nothing failed.
Confirmed by injecting that drift, which now reports it.

The three appearance providers each adapted the auth context to
AppearanceAuth with identical code, putting the shape of auth back in three
places that widening cache ownership would have to find. useAppearanceCacheOwner
now does it once.

useTheme.test.ts cleared storage.KEYS between cases, but appearanceCache
writes namespaced keys and an owner pointer that are not in that list, so
both survived and the suite was order-dependent. It clears the store, as
storage.test.ts already did.

The abs_smart_collection_store comment is reworded rather than given back its
SQL quotes: gofmt folds a pair of apostrophes in a doc comment into a
typographic quote, which is how it became one in the first place.

Reported by CodeRabbit review on #479.
2026-07-27 00:40:04 +00:00
QuickandClaude Opus 5 d8faf83c6e fix(settings): make the settings contract enforceable and fix the appearance cache
The contract manifest landed as a document nothing checked. This makes it a
mechanism, and fixes the one defect in the change set that hurt users on merge
rather than at cutover.

Web appearance cache. useTheme cleared the cache for any account whose stamp
did not match and never repopulated it — the only writers were the four
user-action setters — so every upgrading user lost their warm start on every
load, not once, and x-large-text and high-contrast users lost theirs too. The
owner-stamp protocol is replaced with per-account key namespacing
(`silo-theme:7`): a foreign value is absent rather than present-and-distrusted,
so nothing has to be deleted, the first account keeps its warm start, and there
is no shared stamp for a second tab, a stale debounce timer, or an out-of-order
effect to race on. Widening ownership to profile scope, which this manifest
requires, is now a change to appearanceCacheOwner alone. Adds the API-to-cache
mirror useTheme was missing, cancels pending debounced writes across an account
change, and re-seeds provider state during render so no frame paints the
previous account's look.

Canonicalization. writeCanonical used json.Marshal, which HTML-escapes < > and
&, and canonicalNumber used Go's 'g' format — both diverge from RFC 8785, so
the first label containing an ampersand or bound below 1e-4 would have forked
the server's ETag from every conforming client. Output is now byte-identical to
ECMAScript String() across the edge cases, verified against node. The ETag also
covers the value schemas, which decide what the server accepts and previously
could change while the tag stood still. All four derived representations are
memoized; a conditional GET no longer costs a full parse and re-serialize.

Validation. strictUnmarshal's decoder.More() answered false for a stray ] or },
so `true]` validated as a boolean. Enum matching compared fmt.Sprintf tokens, so
the string "3" satisfied an integer member. Declared steps were never enforced.
The language pattern rejected tags both mobile platforms emit unprompted
(en_US, ca-ES-valencia, ar-EG-u-nu-latn) and never normalized case, so en-US and
en-us were two rows for one preference; NormalizeValue now canonicalizes on the
shared path.

Manifest. show_forced_subtitles defaulted false where the server column is NOT
NULL DEFAULT true, which would have turned forced subtitles off for every
profile that never touched it. preferred_quality declared 13 members where the
planner speaks 6 and collapses the rest to auto. metadata_language's allowlist
was bound to the very column it migrates from. subtitle-appearance pinned
fontFamily to three families while Apple stores any installed system font.
Registers five user-facing settings the clients already ship, and corrects three
notes that described Android behaviour that was not true.

Enforcement. The package had no non-test callers, so MustLoad never ran; it now
loads and logs at startup. The inventory test compared the manifest against a
hand-copied map and could not see the drift it named; it now iterates
settingsRegistry and checks defaults too — both verified to fail on injected
drift. Adds .github/workflows/ci.yml, the repo's first CI that runs go test,
go vet, gofmt, and the frontend suite. Known pre-existing failures are named
individually in the Makefile so everything else stays gated and the list can
only shrink.

Part of #135

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-26 15:24:33 +00:00
QuickandClaude Opus 5 5933ac0bf2 feat(settings): add the canonical settings contract manifest
First implementation step for the cross-platform settings contract (#376).
Adds the artifact everything else depends on: the manifest, its JSON Schema,
the object value schemas, and a Go loader that validates the whole thing at
load time. No routes, no storage, no behavior change — nothing reads this yet.

contracts/settings/v1/ holds the artifact at a stable path because clients
vendor it and generate bindings from it. The embed directive has to sit beside
it (go:embed cannot reach outside its own directory), so that directory is a
tiny Go package containing nothing else; loading and validation live in
internal/settingscontract.

38 definitions: 35 remote, 3 contract-known client_local. That covers every key
the legacy registry accepts, every unregistered key the extension bag was
silently accepting from the web client, every unregistered device key Android
writes, and the profile preference columns that become settings.

Registering the previously-unregistered keys is where the drift shows up, and
the manifest records each case in a notes field:

- ui_theme, ui_text_scale, ui_text_weight, ui_high_contrast,
  ui_custom_theme_vars, and ui_custom_css reached the server only because
  keyUsesUserScope returns true for any unregistered key. They are now typed,
  renamed to the dotted convention every other key uses, and moved to profile
  scope per the design.
- player.match_frame_rate and player.sleep_timer_default_minutes are written by
  Android against a server that does not register them, so every write and reset
  is currently rejected. Registered.
- player.next_up_prompt_seconds is Android's alias for
  playback.next_up_prompt_seconds and does not become a definition; the test
  matrix pins it as a migration alias.
- player.playback_speed is capped at 3.0, matching the server rather than
  Android's 4.0.
- subtitle_appearance becomes playback.subtitle_appearance. Every other
  canonical key carries a domain prefix, and preserving accidental key names is
  an explicit non-goal of the design.

Validation is deliberately stricter than the schema can express. Beyond shape,
it enforces that a resolution order ends in "default", that it only resolves
scopes the definition allows, and — the one most likely to bite — that every
writable scope is actually read, so a setting cannot accept writes at a scope it
will never honor. Defaults are validated against their own value schema, so a
default that violates its own range or enum fails at load. Revision tags are
checked to never run ahead of the manifest revision, which is what makes
revision-aware client filtering trustworthy. Ceiling and floor policy
constraints are rejected on unordered types, where capping would silently do
nothing; playback.preferred_quality's enum is therefore ordered ascending.

ValidateValue is the single validation path, so the mutation endpoint, the
migration, and the manifest's own default checks cannot diverge later. Numbers
decode through json.Number so an integer setting rejects 30.5 rather than
truncating, and object values validate against their referenced JSON Schema
instead of accepting arbitrary JSON the way validateJSONSetting does today.

Canonicalization implements RFC 8785 over the value domain the contract uses:
sorted keys, no insignificant whitespace, ECMAScript number formatting. The
digest is the ETag, and PublicBytes strips maintainer notes so the served
manifest never carries internal commentary.

Promotes santhosh-tekuri/jsonschema/v6 from indirect to direct.

Verification: 124 tests pass across 16 cases; golangci-lint clean;
make verify-local-paths passes. Two failures in internal/api/handlers
(TestRemoveJellyfinCompatWebDisablesWebSetting, the playback v3 seek recovery
test) reproduce unchanged on main and are unrelated.

Part of #376.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-07-26 15:24:32 +00:00