Files
silo-server/internal/playback/remux.go
T
ee9356aab3 fix(playback): claim Safari DV/HDR10 decode evidence and preserve dvvC in remuxes (#617)
* fix(playback): claim Safari DV/HDR10 decode evidence and preserve dvvC

Follow-up to #613 for #609: Safari 26 reports dynamic-range: standard even
on an XDR display, and answers canPlayType "probably" only for dvh1/hvc1
sample entries, never dvhe/hev1. The web probe gated every structured HDR
claim on that media query and probed only dvhe, so the planner still saw
empty hdr_details and terminated with hdr_transcode_unsupported.

- Run the Dolby Vision and HDR10 shape probes unconditionally; the
  dynamic-range query survives only as the best-effort hdr output boolean.
- Probe dvh1+dvhe per DV profile and hvc1+hev1 for the exact HDR10
  Media Capabilities shape; either definitive answer earns the claim.
- Tag preserved-DV remuxes dvh1 with -strict unofficial: FFmpeg omits the
  dvvC configuration record under either tag without it, so the previous
  dvhe output carried no DV signaling at all.
- Scale the screen-derived max_resolution by devicePixelRatio so 2x
  panels stop advertising 1080p.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(playback): align DV/HDR10 claims with the sample entries the remux emits

Review follow-ups on #617 (Codex P1s):

- Probe only dvh1: a browser answering "probably" solely for dvhe has
  given no evidence for the dvh1-tagged file the preserve remux delivers,
  so that answer no longer earns a Dolby Vision claim; such browsers keep
  the validated HDR10 fallback.
- Label the explicit v3 HDR10 strip output hvc1 so the file matches the
  hvc1 evidence the web probe accepts; legacy/auto strips keep hev1.
- Cover preserve tagging for profiles 5 and 8, and exercise the
  mode-to-argument mapping through StartRemuxWithDVMode instead of
  passing the tag flag directly.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(playback): name the subtitle when burn-in alone forces a refused transcode

Selecting a PGS/VOBSUB track on a client without a bitmap renderer forces
a burn-in transcode. When that transcode cannot run, the terminal blamed
the HDR pipeline (hdr_transcode_unsupported) or the 4K policy
(no_alternate_version) — problems that were not blocking playback, since
deselecting the subtitle restores the previous route.

- When the burn requirement is the sole trigger of the adaptation, the
  HDR and 4K-policy terminals emit subtitle_conversion_unsupported with
  a message naming the burn requirement and the actual blocker. A range
  the client genuinely cannot take keeps the HDR terminal.
- describePlanTerminal passes the server's subtitle message through
  instead of flattening every subtitle_* reason to one generic sentence.
- The web player toasts the refusal when it rolls the subtitle selection
  back; previously the only surface was the quality menu, which a user
  who just picked a subtitle has no reason to open.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(playback): require decode evidence for the exact hvc1 entry and gate the disabled-transcode subtitle terminal

Review follow-ups on #617:

- The HDR10 probe accepts only hvc1.2.4.L153.B0: the explicit v3 strip
  remux labels its output hvc1, so an hev1-only decodingInfo answer is
  evidence for bytes Silo never sends and earns no claim (Codex P1).
- The disabled-transcode branch blames the subtitle only when the burn
  requirement was the sole adaptation trigger; other causes keep
  transcoding_disabled. In practice a bitmap selection without transcode
  terminals in the subtitle policy before this branch, but the guard
  keeps the sole-cause invariant if that ordering ever changes
  (CodeRabbit / Codex P2).
- Protocol doc scopes the hvc1 labeling to the explicit v3 strip path;
  legacy/auto strips keep hev1 (CodeRabbit).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-12 21:14:52 -04:00

449 lines
18 KiB
Go

package playback
import (
"bytes"
"context"
"fmt"
"io"
"log/slog"
"net/http"
"os"
"os/exec"
"strconv"
"strings"
"sync"
"github.com/Silo-Server/silo-server/internal/httpstream"
)
var (
resolvedFFmpegPath string
ffmpegOnce sync.Once
doviRPUMu sync.Mutex
doviRPUCache map[string]bool
)
// ffmpegBinary returns the path to the ffmpeg binary.
// Resolved once at first call, then cached for the process lifetime.
func ffmpegBinary() string {
ffmpegOnce.Do(func() {
const jellyfinPath = "/usr/lib/jellyfin-ffmpeg/ffmpeg"
if _, err := exec.LookPath(jellyfinPath); err == nil {
resolvedFFmpegPath = jellyfinPath
return
}
resolvedFFmpegPath = "ffmpeg"
})
return resolvedFFmpegPath
}
// ResolveFFmpegPath returns the ffmpeg binary the playback pipeline executes
// for the given configured path: the configured path when set, otherwise the
// process-global discovery (jellyfin-ffmpeg install, then PATH). Capability
// probes must resolve through this same function so a feature advertised at
// planning time is guaranteed present in the binary that later runs.
func ResolveFFmpegPath(configured string) string {
if configured = strings.TrimSpace(configured); configured != "" {
return configured
}
return ffmpegBinary()
}
// supportsDoviRPUFilter reports whether the given FFmpeg binary can strip
// Dolby Vision RPU metadata via the dovi_rpu bitstream filter (FFmpeg 7.1+).
// The enhancement layer itself is dropped by stream mapping, so stripping the
// RPUs yields a clean HDR10 base layer. Probed once per binary path.
func supportsDoviRPUFilter(bin string) bool {
doviRPUMu.Lock()
defer doviRPUMu.Unlock()
if available, ok := doviRPUCache[bin]; ok {
return available
}
out, err := exec.Command(bin, "-hide_banner", "-bsfs").Output()
available := err == nil && bytes.Contains(out, []byte("dovi_rpu"))
if !available {
slog.Warn("ffmpeg lacks the dovi_rpu bitstream filter (needs FFmpeg 7.1+); validated Profile 7 HDR10 remux is disabled", "ffmpeg", bin)
}
if doviRPUCache == nil {
doviRPUCache = make(map[string]bool)
}
doviRPUCache[bin] = available
return available
}
// remuxDVProfile neutralizes a Dolby Vision profile the local ffmpeg cannot
// handle. Profile 7 is the only profile that triggers an RPU strip in
// buildRemuxArgs; when the strip is unavailable — the dovi_rpu filter is
// missing, or this source's RPU cannot be parsed — the remux must still start
// (an unknown bitstream filter aborts ffmpeg immediately, and a filter that
// rejects every packet hangs the session), so fall back to the pre-strip
// behavior instead of failing playback. Only the legacy/auto mode takes this
// route; the explicit v3 strip recipe fails loudly instead, because it has
// promised the client an HDR10 output it could not then produce.
func remuxDVProfile(dvProfile int, canStripRPU bool) int {
if dvProfile == 7 && !canStripRPU {
return 0
}
return dvProfile
}
// RemuxSession represents a running ffmpeg remux process that copies
// codecs to a new container format without re-encoding.
type RemuxSession struct {
cmd *exec.Cmd
cancel context.CancelFunc
outputPipe io.ReadCloser
}
// RemuxDVMode makes Profile 7 handling an explicit byte-level recipe choice.
// The empty/legacy mode exists only for pre-v3 callers and old stream tokens.
type RemuxDVMode string
const (
RemuxDVLegacyAutoV3 RemuxDVMode = "legacy_auto"
RemuxDVPreserveV3 RemuxDVMode = "preserve"
RemuxDVStripToHDR10V3 RemuxDVMode = "strip_to_hdr10"
RemuxDVRejectP7V3 RemuxDVMode = "reject_profile_7"
)
// buildRemuxArgs constructs the ffmpeg argument list for a remux operation.
// The args perform codec copy (-c copy) into the target container format,
// using fragmented output for streaming (frag_keyframe+delay_moov+default_base_moof) and
// pipe:1 for stdout output.
// When transcodeAudio is true, video is copied but audio is transcoded to
// stereo AAC (handles cases like DTS/TrueHD that browsers cannot decode).
// dvProfile is the file's Dolby Vision profile (0 = none). Profile 7 remuxes
// strip DV RPUs: the enhancement layer is dropped by the video map below, so
// the RPUs would dangle — stripping yields a clean HDR10 base layer (the
// Apple-parity fallback for devices without a P7 decoder). Profile 8 RPUs
// stay: the base layer is self-contained and DV clients can render it.
func buildRemuxArgs(filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int, tagSampleEntry, audioOnly bool) []string {
return buildRemuxArgsWithAudioV3(filePath, outputFormat, seekSeconds, transcodeAudio, audioTrackIndex, dvProfile, tagSampleEntry, audioOnly, 0, 0)
}
func buildRemuxArgsWithAudioV3(filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int, tagSampleEntry, audioOnly bool, targetAudioChannels, targetAudioBitrateKbps int) []string {
args := []string{
"-nostdin",
"-hide_banner",
"-loglevel", "error",
// Cap the input probe to speed up startup on large MKV containers
// (defaults scan up to 5 seconds / several MB). Mirrors the transcode
// pipeline, which has run these caps in production without issue.
"-fflags", "+genpts+fastseek",
"-analyzeduration", "3000000",
"-probesize", "5000000",
}
// Add seek if requested (before input for fast seek).
if seekSeconds > 0 {
args = append(args, "-ss", strconv.FormatFloat(seekSeconds, 'f', 3, 64))
if transcodeAudio {
// In copy mode (-c:v copy) video must start at a keyframe, but
// accurate_seek (the default) trims re-encoded audio to the exact
// seek point. This mismatch causes A/V desync equal to the gap
// between the keyframe and the seek point. Disabling accurate seek
// keeps both streams aligned at the keyframe boundary.
args = append(args, "-noaccurate_seek")
}
}
args = append(args, "-i", filePath)
// Strip metadata/chapters and skip subtitle/data streams — the remux
// output is fed to an HTML <video> tag, none of it is consumed.
args = append(args,
"-map_metadata", "-1",
"-map_chapters", "-1",
)
// A planned video remux must fail if the promised video stream disappeared
// or became unreadable. Only positively identified audio-only media may
// make the video map optional.
videoMap := "0:V:0"
if audioOnly {
videoMap += "?"
}
args = append(args, "-map", videoMap)
if audioTrackIndex >= 0 {
args = append(args, "-map", fmt.Sprintf("0:a:%d?", audioTrackIndex))
} else {
args = append(args, "-map", "0:a:0?")
}
args = append(args, "-sn", "-dn")
if dvProfile == 7 {
args = append(args, "-bsf:v", "dovi_rpu=strip=1")
if tagSampleEntry {
// The explicit v3 strip recipe promised the client plain HDR10.
// Safari's media element only answers "probably" for hvc1 — the
// sample entry Apple's HLS authoring spec requires — so relabel
// FFmpeg's default hev1 to match the evidence the web probe
// collects. Stripped output carries no DOVI record, so no -strict
// relaxation is needed. Legacy/auto strips keep hev1.
args = append(args, "-tag:v", "hvc1")
}
} else if (dvProfile == 5 || dvProfile == 8) && tagSampleEntry {
// FFmpeg carries the DOVI configuration record into MP4 but otherwise
// labels copied HEVC as hev1. Media3 keys decoder selection from the
// sample entry, and Safari's media element only answers "probably" for
// dvh1 — the sample entry Apple's HLS authoring spec calls for — so tag
// dvh1. FFmpeg refuses to write the dvvC configuration record box under
// either tag without -strict unofficial; dvh1 plus -strict unofficial is
// verified (7.1.4) to retain the full record. Media3 accepts both sample
// entries, so Android preserve consumers are unaffected. Only the
// explicit v3 preserve recipe opts in: legacy web/jellycompat consumers
// keep the pre-v3 hev1 labeling their demuxers accept.
args = append(args, "-tag:v", "dvh1", "-strict", "unofficial")
}
if transcodeAudio {
channels, bitrateKbps := resolvedAACOutputV3(targetAudioChannels, targetAudioBitrateKbps)
// Video copy + AAC encode is effectively single-threaded work.
// ffmpeg's default auto-threading spawns one filter thread per CPU
// core for the implicit downmix/resampler, all idle. Pin to one.
args = append(args,
"-threads", "1",
"-filter_threads", "1",
"-filter_complex_threads", "1",
"-c:v", "copy",
"-c:a", "aac",
"-ac", strconv.Itoa(channels),
"-b:a", strconv.Itoa(bitrateKbps)+"k",
)
} else {
args = append(args, "-c", "copy")
}
args = append(args,
"-avoid_negative_ts", "make_zero",
"-f", outputFormat,
// delay_moov lets the MP4 muxer inspect the first audio packet before
// writing codec configuration. empty_moov fails immediately for copied
// E-AC-3/Atmos tracks because their frame size is not known at header time.
"-movflags", "frag_keyframe+delay_moov+default_base_moof",
"pipe:1",
)
return args
}
// StartRemux starts an ffmpeg process that copies codecs to a new container.
// When transcodeAudio is false the command is:
//
// ffmpeg -i {input} -c copy -f {format} -movflags frag_keyframe+delay_moov+default_base_moof pipe:1
//
// When transcodeAudio is true video is copied but audio is transcoded to AAC.
// The caller must call Close() when done to clean up resources.
func StartRemux(ctx context.Context, filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int) (*RemuxSession, error) {
return StartRemuxWithDVMode(ctx, filePath, outputFormat, seekSeconds, transcodeAudio, audioTrackIndex, dvProfile, RemuxDVLegacyAutoV3, "")
}
// StartRemuxWithDVMode starts a remux with explicit Dolby Vision behavior.
// ffmpegPath selects the binary to execute (empty = process-global discovery);
// v3 callers must pass the configured playback path so the strip capability
// promised by the planner's probe holds for the binary that actually runs.
func StartRemuxWithDVMode(ctx context.Context, filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int, mode RemuxDVMode, ffmpegPath string) (*RemuxSession, error) {
return startRemuxWithOptions(ctx, filePath, outputFormat, seekSeconds, transcodeAudio, audioTrackIndex, dvProfile, mode, ffmpegPath, false, 0, 0)
}
func startRemuxWithOptions(ctx context.Context, filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int, mode RemuxDVMode, ffmpegPath string, audioOnly bool, targetAudioChannels, targetAudioBitrateKbps int) (*RemuxSession, error) {
ctx, cancel := context.WithCancel(ctx)
bin := ResolveFFmpegPath(ffmpegPath)
effectiveProfile := dvProfile
tagSampleEntry := false
switch mode {
case "", RemuxDVLegacyAutoV3:
effectiveProfile = remuxDVProfile(dvProfile, supportsDoviRPUFilter(bin) &&
(dvProfile != 7 || sharedDVRPUProbe.CanStrip(ctx, bin, filePath)))
case RemuxDVStripToHDR10V3:
if dvProfile != 7 && dvProfile != 8 {
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("Dolby Vision HDR10 strip requires profile 7 or 8")
}
if !supportsDoviRPUFilter(bin) {
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("Dolby Vision HDR10 remux requires the dovi_rpu bitstream filter")
}
// The planner refuses this recipe for a source that fails the probe,
// so reaching here means a session or stream token minted before the
// verdict was known. Fail definitively: copying the base layer without
// the strip would leave dangling RPUs (the decoder stall this recipe
// exists to prevent) while still claiming HDR10, and attempting the
// strip anyway is the per-packet rejection that hangs the session. The
// next start re-plans against the now-cached verdict.
if !sharedDVRPUProbe.CanStrip(ctx, bin, filePath) {
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("this source's Dolby Vision RPU cannot be stripped to HDR10")
}
// buildRemuxArgs uses profile 7 as the explicit strip sentinel; the
// filter is equally required for a compatible profile 8 base layer.
// The explicit recipe also labels the output hvc1: the web HDR10
// probe collects evidence for that sample entry, and the plan must
// deliver the shape it validated. Legacy/auto strips keep hev1.
effectiveProfile = 7
tagSampleEntry = true
case RemuxDVPreserveV3:
if dvProfile == 7 {
// The remux maps only the base-layer stream, so dual-layer P7
// cannot be preserved: the EL is dropped and its RPUs would
// dangle. Callers must strip to HDR10 or transcode instead.
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("Dolby Vision profile 7 cannot be preserved in a progressive remux")
}
tagSampleEntry = true
case RemuxDVRejectP7V3:
if dvProfile == 7 {
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("profile 7 remux is not eligible")
}
default:
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("unknown remux Dolby Vision mode %q", mode)
}
args := buildRemuxArgsWithAudioV3(filePath, outputFormat, seekSeconds, transcodeAudio, audioTrackIndex, effectiveProfile, tagSampleEntry, audioOnly, targetAudioChannels, targetAudioBitrateKbps)
cmd := exec.CommandContext(ctx, bin, args...)
stdout, err := cmd.StdoutPipe()
if err != nil {
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("stdout pipe: %w", err)
}
if err := cmd.Start(); err != nil {
cancel()
return nil, fmt.Errorf("start ffmpeg: %w", err)
}
return &RemuxSession{
cmd: cmd,
cancel: cancel,
outputPipe: stdout,
}, nil
}
// Read implements io.Reader, piping ffmpeg stdout to the caller.
func (s *RemuxSession) Read(p []byte) (int, error) {
return s.outputPipe.Read(p)
}
// Close stops the ffmpeg process and cleans up all resources.
// It is safe to call Close multiple times.
func (s *RemuxSession) Close() error {
s.cancel()
// Drain the pipe so cmd.Wait does not block.
_, _ = io.Copy(io.Discard, s.outputPipe)
return s.cmd.Wait()
}
// containerMIME maps output format names to MIME types for HTTP responses.
func containerMIME(format string) string {
switch format {
case "mp4":
return "video/mp4"
case "webm":
return "video/webm"
case "matroska":
return "video/x-matroska"
case "mpegts":
return "video/mp2t"
default:
return "application/octet-stream"
}
}
// RemuxServeOptions carries the optional serving concerns that not every
// caller sets, keeping the positional argument list from growing further.
type RemuxServeOptions struct {
// DVMode is the explicitly declared Dolby Vision recipe. The zero value
// decodes as the legacy auto behavior, matching old stream tokens.
DVMode RemuxDVMode
// FFmpegPath selects the binary to execute (empty = global discovery).
FFmpegPath string
// ContentType overrides the container-derived response type. Audio-only
// sources mux an audio-only fMP4, which must not be announced as video.
ContentType string
// AudioOnly permits the otherwise-mandatory video map to be absent.
AudioOnly bool
// TargetAudioChannels and TargetAudioBitrateKbps freeze the planned AAC
// output. Zero values retain the historical stereo 192 kbps behavior.
TargetAudioChannels int
TargetAudioBitrateKbps int
}
// RemuxContentType returns the override required for an audio-only fMP4.
func RemuxContentType(audioOnly bool) string {
if audioOnly {
return AudioOnlyRemuxMIMEV3
}
return ""
}
// ServeRemux streams a remuxed file to the HTTP response.
// It starts an ffmpeg remux session and copies the output directly to the
// response writer. The response is streamed (chunked transfer) since the
// total size is not known in advance.
// When transcodeAudio is true, audio is transcoded to AAC while video is copied.
func ServeRemux(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request, filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int) error {
return ServeRemuxWithOptions(w, r, filePath, outputFormat, seekSeconds, transcodeAudio, audioTrackIndex, dvProfile, RemuxServeOptions{})
}
// ServeRemuxWithDVMode streams an explicitly declared Dolby Vision recipe.
// ffmpegPath selects the binary to execute (empty = process-global discovery).
func ServeRemuxWithDVMode(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request, filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int, mode RemuxDVMode, ffmpegPath string) error {
return ServeRemuxWithOptions(w, r, filePath, outputFormat, seekSeconds, transcodeAudio, audioTrackIndex, dvProfile, RemuxServeOptions{DVMode: mode, FFmpegPath: ffmpegPath})
}
// ServeRemuxWithOptions is the full remux transport, taking its optional
// serving concerns as a struct.
func ServeRemuxWithOptions(w http.ResponseWriter, r *http.Request, filePath, outputFormat string, seekSeconds float64, transcodeAudio bool, audioTrackIndex int, dvProfile int, opts RemuxServeOptions) error {
mode, ffmpegPath := opts.DVMode, opts.FFmpegPath
// Remux output streams for the length of the title; roll the write
// deadline with progress instead of the server's absolute WriteTimeout.
w = httpstream.NewRollingDeadlineWriter(w)
// Check file exists before starting ffmpeg to return a proper 404.
// Headers must be written before streaming begins, so we can't detect
// ffmpeg errors after WriteHeader(200) has been sent.
if _, err := os.Stat(filePath); err != nil {
if os.IsNotExist(err) {
http.Error(w, "file not found", http.StatusNotFound)
return err
}
http.Error(w, "failed to access file", http.StatusInternalServerError)
return err
}
session, err := startRemuxWithOptions(r.Context(), filePath, outputFormat, seekSeconds, transcodeAudio, audioTrackIndex, dvProfile, mode, ffmpegPath, opts.AudioOnly, opts.TargetAudioChannels, opts.TargetAudioBitrateKbps)
if err != nil {
http.Error(w, "failed to start remux", http.StatusInternalServerError)
return err
}
defer session.Close()
contentType := opts.ContentType
if contentType == "" {
contentType = containerMIME(outputFormat)
}
w.Header().Set("Content-Type", contentType)
w.Header().Set("Transfer-Encoding", "chunked")
w.WriteHeader(http.StatusOK)
// Stream ffmpeg output to the HTTP response.
buf := make([]byte, 32*1024) // 32 KB buffer
for {
n, readErr := session.Read(buf)
if n > 0 {
if _, writeErr := w.Write(buf[:n]); writeErr != nil {
return nil // Client disconnected.
}
if f, ok := w.(http.Flusher); ok {
f.Flush()
}
}
if readErr != nil {
return nil // EOF or error — done streaming.
}
}
}